Fiat 500 Forum banner

Does fiat need a 6 speed manual

1 reading
18K views 21 replies 18 participants last post by  Mvander  
#1 ·
I have heard a few people complain about the gearing on the 500 manual, while I find the 6 speed auto very well done. Question is, would a 6 speed manual help things? Heck, there are a few new cars with 8 speed automatics....just how many flippin gears does a car need?
 
#3 ·
I would say not really useful but I could be 100% wrong, my thinking is the RPMs would drop pretty low and 6th gear would have so little power it seems almost pointless. That said I am sure every aspect would be adjusted to accommodate an additional gear so taking that into account it might be ok, just basing my thoughts on my other ride and how much power/RPMs differs from 5th to 6th. I'm sure there are many here that have and will share knowledge which may better explain what I am saying and also likely my reasoning will not make as much sense as it does to me now...but I like learning so I look forward to seeing more educated answers!
 
#4 ·
The tranny is the size of a football. It would have to be redesigned made larger which wouldn't fit in the engine bay, so the car would have to be redesigned as well. If they did add a 6th gear, every gear ratio would be changed so 6th would work. They wouldn't just throw a taller gear to what they have.

Engineering.....It's a blast
 
#8 · (Edited)
I'd love the 6 speed, but it's costs as usual. It could make a real nice 1-2 and 2-3 gear set for improved acceleration, and a taller 6th for mpg.

It would be the bees knees.

FYI the existing tranny in our cars is made into a 6 speed in EU, that's why we have an unusually long gate to reverse (6th used to reside below 5th).
 
  • Like
Reactions: sportflyer
#9 ·
Exactly...

I'd love the 6 speed, but it's costs as usual. It could make a real nice 1-2 and 2-3 gear set for improved acceleration, and a taller 6th for mpg.

It would be the bees knees.

FYI the existing tranny in our cars is made into a 6 speed in EU, that's why we have an unusually long gate to reverse (6th used to reside above 5th).
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^This^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
 
#10 · (Edited)
not real necessary imo. the 6th gear would only be marginally taller than 5th is now. i agree with others, if they want to add expense, start stop would be a better choice.
 
#15 · (Edited)
Until they redesign the chassis it won't happen. The 6 spd MT is TOO wide to fit with the additional 'third load path' added for crash protection in N.A. 500's. I agree it would be nice to have and certain models of the regular 500 in Europe DO have the 6 spd but they don't have the additional safety mods to the chassis. The Abarth in Europe ONLY has the 5 Spd MT. I don't know if the more upscale Abarths with the flappy paddle shifter dual clutch trannies have 6 spds or not.
 
#13 · (Edited)
At 65mph in fifth I feel like I should have one more gear reduction available. The engine just seems to sound as if I should still shift one more time. However, I agree, the use of space in the 500's engine compartment is extraordinary as is. Adding an additional gear - even if that gear were made to the second and third gear ratios with both becoming a taller gear ratio followed by a slight redesign of the 4 and 5 gear ratios - would not fit into the present configuration of the 500. If the sixth gear ratio could be fitted to the transmission while, say, giving up no more than an extra inch of leg room on the passenger side, that would IMO be worth it.
 
#17 ·
It depends on how they do the 6 gears.

I back to back test drove an Abarth and a Dodge Dart (same engine). The Abarth gear spacing is a bit wide. Several times the lower gear was a bit short and the higher gear too long.

But, the 6 speed in the Dart seemed to have the same gearing 1 - 5, but with a VERY tall 6th gear. As in less than 2000 RPM at 60 MPH. Which required a 2 gear downshift to do anything.

I would like to see a 6 speed in the Abarth, but with the same 1st and what is now 5th, be 6th, and space the intermediate gears a bit closer together.